Soooooooooooo…movie review time…
Went and saw Sex in the City last night with Andrea. I loved the HBO series and was really looking forward to seeing the movie…and to see if all the hype measured up to my expectations.
I have to say, I am very split on what I think. I liked the movie, but the more I think about it I was really disappointed at the same time…and the more that time passes, the more disappointed I feel. Its a happy-go-lucky movie, with lots of fun scenes, clothes, and characters…and definitely a great movie for girls night out. But when comparing the movie characters to those from the series, I felt almost like they were completely different people.
The gay guys (Standford and Anthony) - These two couldn’t stand each other when someone tried to set them up on a date in the series, but now they’re friends and even kissed on new years?
The assistant (Louise) - I didn’t really understand why her character was in the movie at all…to bring Carrie "back to life"? The entire character could have been dropped from the movie and it wouldn’t have made a difference for me.
Charlotte - I felt like Charlotte was hardly even a relevant character in the movie! It didn’t seem like she had half as much story line as the other girls. And I thought her pregnancy would have been "more" of the movie. The movie was half over before she was pregnant…and then in the next scene she was giving birth! And they were always showing her little girl (Lilly) "hanging out" with the girls…which I don’t think is realistic. She probably would have gotten a sitter when all the girls were going to Carrie’s to drink champagne and go through her clothes…and again for the girls night before Carrie’s wedding. PLUS, the girl hardly said peep throughout the entire movie.
Samantha - Living in California?! I don’t think Samantha ever would have moved from New York. Plus, I thought it was sooooo obvious that they would make Samantha go back to her "slutty" ways. There was really nothing else to do with her character at the end of the series. PS, Samantha totally would have slept with the hottie neighbor post-breakup…maybe even pre-breakup!
Miranda - She was a big character in the movie…I think the biggest character after Carrie. She made a HUGE thing about the affair, so I had a really hard time accepting that she would take Steve back, just like that. They met on the bridge and then she was sooooo happy he was there. Of course he was going to be there…he was the one who had the affair and was begging to have her back! I understand that he was happy…but I think she was a little to eager to get back together with a guy that cheated on her 6 months ago. Especially when she was coming to terms with the fact that she deep down resented him a bit for changing who she was as a person. I thought they should have gone a little deeper into that. Plus…I thought that was a seriously crude sex scene at the end…didn’t think that that did anything for the movie or the story line.
Carrie (and Big) - I guess I was most surprised with Carrie and Big. I don’t think that these 2 would ever get married…to much bad history, and not in either of their natures based on what we learned about them in the series. Realistically if Carrie brought up marriage in the kitchen over dinner…I think Big would have blown it off. I thought that it might turn out believeable at the end when they were lying on the closet floor wondering why they even even considered getting married….but then big proposed again?! LAME! I think it would have been 100 times better if he didn’t, and they just stayed together…unmarried. Plus, the engagement with the shoe at the end was just way over the top. And I think they should have kept the apartment…which was another kind of unnecessary storyline in the movie. PS, Carrie SLEEPS in a long pearl necklace?!?!
I was pretty much just turned off by the fact that it was like they took at the characters from the HBO series and turned them into the polar opposites of who they were and what they were doing in the series season finale. I mean, what else did they have to write about if they didn’t do that? It just made the movie story lines a little too obvious for my taste.
Another thing is that all in all, I feel like there were a lot of "props" in the movie…the apartment, the assistant, the daughter, the sexy neighbor…Samantha’s dog…lots of story lines that didn’t even get tapped into, so they weren’t really entertwined in the story at all. Bizarre…it left me feeling like the movie was very incomplete.